From the novel: Sean felt Lauren idly caress his arm, and he looked across the street at Jimmy. Definitely a good catch on your part! Jimmy then tells Dave Boyle that this is where he killed Harris years before for sending him to prison. And Jimmy's head swiveled. With Sean Penn, Tim Robbins, Kevin Bacon, Emmy Rossum. Celeste reminds Sean that Jimmy killed Dave, and Sean can only say that he knows but has no proof. Boston is a pretty major US city. mystic river ending who killed katie. However, I unconsciously made that exact assumption when I watched the movie recently, so I think it would have been a reasonable one, even if it was not in the script. Karma Houdini: Jimmy murdered "Just Ray" Harris and got off by agreeing to pay his family a monthly sum of $500. Dave was fighting himself a war as a child molester. After he was abducted by those guys in the opening scene, he changed into a complete person. Said you might know where he is. Annabeth assures him that it's never wrong to do whatever you have to do for those you love. Dave never got counseling to cope with the event; he hasn't even told his wife Celeste (Marcia Gay Harden). The 25 Best Mystery Movies of the 21st Century. They want to talk to Dave about it.". As Sean gets down on his hands and knees to look down ... YOUNG JIMMY Your dad kill you for writing your name, too? Mystic River is set in a Boston community which is rocked by the fatal shooting of a young woman. 7 Mystic River is set in a Boston community which is rocked by the fatal shooting of a young woman. Moving between employers who don't recruit from each other? How to mitigate the risk of riding on highways. How come the cops didn't find the gun thrown in the shallow river? Meanwhile, Sean’s estranged wife finally speaks to him. If it took him the rest of his life, he was going to bring him down. One boy got into the car, two did not, and something terrible happened — something that ended … How would you have a space ship set out on a journey to a distant planet, but find themselves arriving back home without realising it? After Dave’s death, the police discover that two 13-year-old boys murdered Katie; one of them is Silent Ray, the younger, mute brother of Katie’s boyfriend, Brendan. You can read the scene here - it starts on page 114 but Sean's quote is on 116. Home; About Denise; Services; Testimonials; Products; Contact; who killed katie in mystic river His increasing mental instability starts to frighten her to the point where she shares her suspicions with Jimmy, which ultimately leads to Dave being fingered in Katie's death. Booking flight tickets for someone in another country? Excellent answer djmadscribbler, except for one detail, and probably why Shiz Z. asked the question: Although the script states that the BPD found the pedophile's body that morning, Kevin Bacon left off the "this morning" phrase from the line in the movie. Climactic Moment: Jimmy kills Dave; Sean arrests Silent Ray and his friend. In 1975, when he was playing hockey with his friends Jimmy and Sean, Dave was tricked and kidnapped by two child molesters. She said Dave's missing. Name any movie with a surprise/twist ending that consists of completely average circumstances. Edit, This question has raised considerable discussion. Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Set in an Irish neighborhood in Boston, Jimmy, Sean, and Dave are three childhood friends who are reunited after a brutal murder takes place. First time flying. How did the Perseverance rover land on Mars with the retro rockets apparently stopped? The movie, “Mystic River” is the story of three boys who grew up together, but were separated by a set of circumstances. Although... Lady Macbeth: Jimmy's wife Annabeth, after he murders Dave. Menu. | When they were children, Sean Devine, Jimmy Marcus, and Dave Boyle were friends. Dave escaped, but he never truly returned to society. What turns out to have happened was that Brendan's brother, Ray Harris Jr, (Spencer Treat Clark) had found his father's gun and that he and a friend decided to have some fun with it. At some point the gun went off, wounding Katie, and she fled into the park (Brendan even suggested that Ray Jr. may have had some motive to shoot Katie, since she was going to take Brendan away from him to Las Vegas). rev 2021.2.26.38663, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Movies & TV Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. How does Dave's childhood trauma affect the course of events in the story? In the woods behind McGill's." Jimmy, Sean, and Dave grew up together and they are the main protagonists in the movie. Sean raised his hand, the index finger pointing out, the thumb cocked like the hammer of a gun, and then he dropped the thumb and fired. Directed by Clint Eastwood. External Reviews Movies & TV Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for movie and TV enthusiasts. But they had his prints on the murder weapon. Clint Eastwood's "Mystic River" is a dark, ominous brooding about a crime in the present that is emotionally linked to a crime in the past. This ignores the fact that Dave's body was left at a different place than where the molester's body was found. Why do we teach the Rational Root Theorem? The Savage brothers had convinced him that Dave was guilty (even though Dave kept trying to convince Jimmy that he killed a pedophile, not Katie). Sean realizes Jimmy must have killed Dave. The movie was really good for the most part but I failed to understand the ending. Though Sean and Celeste know that Jimmy is responsible for Dave’s sudden disappearance, they have no proof. so eventually a father who lost her child and in searching for her killer insanely, he couldn't control his wrath when he found his answer from Dave and immediately killed him.But in the End he regret for this but for the sake of his family he can't surrender … The FAQ items below may give away important plot points. We need to talk to him. He fake admitted that he was the one who killed Katie so that he could escape his current life. ... Jimmy Markum, and Dave … How can, by Raw, Animal Handling be used with a mount? How come the scientist in the second planet is not super old? Clint Eastwood's Mystic River is suffused with lives ruined by violence; in Kill Bill, Quentin Tarantino looks violence in the eye -- and cackles. Sunset, sunrise, and Sean catches the real killers, Ray and his partner in crime (literally). Either they never think about how realistic it is to the viewer or they simply think the viewer won't notice. Recommended SQL Server transaction logs settings for ephemeral databases? Jimmy's shrug is then interpreted as him saying either "Try, if you can," or "I know you will...eventually." Are financial markets "unique" for each "currency pair", or are they simply "translated"? No. It is also pointed out that Jimmy was in anguish over Katie's murder. Besides, Sean knows he'd just be taking another 2 girls' father away from them. Everyone begins to suspect Dave, who was seen with the victim before the murder and then came home later with an injured hand and blood on his clothes, supposedly from a mugging. Were John Baptist and Jesus really related? Most viewers point out that Dave was drunk and wasn't thinking fast. I also think the better plot twist or ending to the movie would be to make you think Dave really DIDN'T do it but then at the last second you find out he did. Jimmy just shrugs as the parade rolls by, and the Mystic River rolls on. Since the body was just found that morning, it makes sense that only Dave mentions it before - he's the only one who knows that they guy is dead. (Dave did kill someone the same night Katie was killed, but it wasn't Katie, rather, a run-of-the-mill child molester). On the night of the murder, Dave comes home with a bloodied hand and a knife wound to his chest. Afraid of the consequences, the two boys followed Katie and killed her to keep from talking. Jimmy and Val go to lunch with Dave, confront him as Katie's killer and kill him despite him protesting his innocence. He also tells Jimmy that the Boston police found the body of a pedophile in the woods behind McGills and they would like to talk with Dave. Resolution: Sean tells Jimmy that Silent Ray was really the killer. Days later, when Dave finally escapes, he is marked by everyone in the neighborhood as "damaged goods." Some viewers interpret the scene during the parade where Sean makes a gun with his fingers and points it at Jimmy as saying, "I'm gonna get you." They held him in captivity in the woods and raped him for four days. I got a call from Celeste Boyle. But then a strange car pulled tip to their street. Unfortunately, Jimmy had no intention of letting Dave live if he confessed. What is the significance of the title "Mystic River"? How can I by-pass a function if already executed? Life Events – Dave is taken at age 11 by two men and sexually violated for four days 2. Dave was the same child molester he talked about. They let him leave and then shortly join him as he is puking by the bank of the river. Jimmy gets it in his head that Dave killed his daughter, and kills Dave, dumping his body in the river. Dave lives with a caring wife, and he passes through the crowds unnoticed and unheard. Later, he kills Dave and also gets off scot-free. Usually 100 to 150 murders per year, possibly more for when the movie is set. As "you should have told me sooner" is by no means a confession by the law's standards. One of the boys, Dave, was kidnapped and raped by two men. Edit, Awards Sean knows that Jimmy killed Dave … I guess "this morning" would have helped, but the ending would still frustrate me as a viewer because it hinges on not just one but two very unlikely events: (1) a second murder having happened on same night as the first, and also (2) second murder undiscovered until just after Dave's death. Why is there a 2 in front of some of these passive component parts? As the cops investigate the murder, several days go by. Karma Houdini: Jimmy murdered "Just Ray" Harris and got off by agreeing to pay his family a monthly sum of $500. In Mystic River, How did listening to the 911 tape solve the case? Thematically very similar is Gone Baby Gone (2007), another crime story set in Boston, also by writer Dennis Lehane. Plus grit, tension and great acting. Reformed convict Jimmy Markum (Sean Penn) and his devoted wife Annabeth (Laura … Edit, Originally the police believe that Katie's death has something to do with her secret relationship with Brendan Harris (Tom Guiry) and suspect that Brendan's father "Just Ray" Harris might have killed Katie because he had a bad past with Jimmy. When Dave falsely confessed, Markum knifed him in the stomach, shot him in the head, and dumped his body in the Mystic River - only a few hours before the real killers were identified. The author hasn't admitted much more than that he liked the name of the river and the various meanings it could have. Jimmy tells Dave, "We bury our sins here (i.e. Sean, Lauren, and Nora watch the parade from outside a coffee shop. Actions: Dave kills a sexual predator but Jimmy believes that Dave kills his daughter,Katie. Why does pressure in a thermos increase after shaking up hot water and soap. Final “closing characteristic moment” for all the characters at the parade in the final scene. Laser-Guided Karma: One of the real killers turns out to be the youngest son of "Just Ray" Harris himself. https://www.charactour.com/hub/characters/view/Jimmy-Markum.Mystic-River Edit, One movie that viewers have mentioned as being similar to Mystic River is Summer of Sam (1999), in which a punk rocker is almost beaten to death when his "friends" conclude that he must be the serial killer known as "Son of Sam", who is terrorizing their section of the Bronx. Celeste becomes suspicious when she cannot find any mention of a wounded mugger in the newspapers. in the Mystic River), Dave. Totally agree about Dave having done it -- in fact, until the end, that's where I thought the movie was going, and I loved it -- such an unusual plot. Others feel that Dave wasn't certain the pedophile was dead or that his body was still there behind McGill's. This becomes worse when she hears Dave give different statements as to the cause of his hand injury. The next day, as the sounds of the parade fill the neighborhood streets, Jimmy confesses to wife Annabeth ( Laura Linney ) that he killed Dave and threw his body in the Mystic. It's simple!Before Jimmy killed Dave,he confronted to Jimmy’s question about his daughter’s murder is that “he did! She was hysterical. They had discovered that the gun used to shoot Katie had once been used in a robbery by Just Ray. Its name comes from a Wampanoag word meaning "big river." A 2001 novel by Dennis Lehane, Mystic River was brought to the screen in 2003 by director Clint Eastwood.The film version starred Sean Penn and Tim Robbins, who both won Oscars for their roles, and Kevin Bacon and Laurence Fishburne.. Years ago, Dave Boyle escaped with his life from mysterious men in Boston. Katie happened to be driving by and crashed the car in order to avoid running over the boy. 2 points Anxiety disorder (Post Traumatic Stress Disorder in combination with social phobia. S-E-A-N. Jimmy smiles. What diagnosis best fits the main character(s) and why? Why hadn't anyone in the entire movie -- particularly the cops -- mentioned that there had been a second murder (the child molester) on the same night as the young woman was killed, presumably in the same vicinity where Dave had been? Laser-Guided Karma: One of the real killers turns out to be the youngest son of "Just Ray" Harris himself. During Mystic River, Dave has flashbacks often of … The next day, as the sounds of the parade fill the neighborhood streets, Jimmy confesses to wife Annabeth (Laura Linney) that he killed Dave and threw his body in the Mystic. Maybe Sean Penn's character goes to jail for murdering Dave and nobody but the viewers ever know the truth. Point taken, I think I commented on another post either concerning this movie or another similar movie situation where I offered that this a really just a writer's technique to make everything seem to work. Eventually the young woman's grief-stricken father confronts Dave, who then says he got the injury and blood from killing a child molester who he saw with an under-age prostitute. Look over again." When Sean sees Jimmy, he mimics shooting him with a finger gun. "You see me, Jimmy? When 19-year-old Katie Markum (Emmy Rossum), daughter of Boston shop-owner Jimmy Markum (Sean Penn), is brutally murdered, Jimmy is reunited with two childhood friends—Sean Devine (Kevin Bacon), who is the detective investigating the case, and Dave Boyle (Tim Robbins), who was abducted off the street and sexually abused for four days when the boys were 11 years old. Dave tries to explain this to Jimmy, but Jimmy kills Dave anyway. In that moment, Sean realizes that Jimmy has killed Dave but allows him to walk away, taking a phone call from his wife Lauren (Tori Davis) who talks with him for the first time and agrees to come home. Metacritic Reviews. Boston police found the body of a guy this morning. He attacked himself that night when Katie was murdered by those kids. Why was Sean Divine embarrassed with his friends in Mystic River? When Jimmy told Dave that he would kill him if he didn't confess to killing Katie, Dave saw that as a way to escape with his life, so he confessed to a crime that he didn't commit. Sean says "Look at me. Everyone begins to suspect Dave, who was seen with the victim before the murder and then came home later with an injured hand and blood on his clothes, supposedly from a mugging. Although... Lady Macbeth: Jimmy's wife Annabeth, after he murders Dave. Is there any way to turn a token into a nontoken? Edit, The ending is left open. An intuitive interpretation of Negative voltage, How to enter a repeating decimal in Mathematica. Is this the grave of a child in Akira Kurosawa's Dreams? by | Feb 17, 2021 | Long Term Care Home Ottawa | Feb 17, 2021 | Long Term Care Home Ottawa The two boys went over to check on her at which point she recognized Ray as her boyfriend's brother. User Ratings As the investigation creeps closer to home, his wife Celeste becomes consumed by suspicion and fear, while Jimmy''s wife, Annabeth, draws her family tighter together in order to weather the storm. Very deserving of Best Picture. The molester's body wasn't found until the morning that Sean went to talk to Jimmy. They hadn't mentioned it before because they didn't know about it. Jimmy's smile broadened. Edit. Living… a relatively normal life in Boston. (high school algebra 2), ApplySides Integrate to equations in differential one-form, Vigenère Cipher problem in competitive programming. As the cops investigate the murder, several days go by. Of course, the very next day, the cops announce that they caught someone else who confessed to killing the young woman -- and by the way, in an unrelated case, a child molester had been killed that same night, and the cops suspect Dave did it. That pretty much precludes the whole concept of a twist, doesn't it? He smiled at Sean. The story seems unbelievable, and the grief-stricken father kills Dave. In present day Boston, he is reunited with his childhood friends, Jimmy … It only takes a minute to sign up. | Later, at the parade, Dave's wife Celeste looks anxiously at the faces of Sean and Jimmy, but they reveal nothing. And he will do the same to Boyle if he killed his daughter, Katie. Oh, and this line of dialogue would be nonsense: "Boston Police found the body of a guy, a pedophile, in the woods behind McGill's. It involves three boyhood friends in an Irish neighborhood of Boston, who were forever marked when one of them was captured by a child molester; as adults, their lives have settled into uneasy routines that are interrupted by the … Visual design changes to the review queues, Opt-in alpha test for a new Stacks editor. They were playing around and one of the boys lied down on the street to startle motorists. It makes you feel like Robbins’ character Dave is truly … Edit, Sean locates a drunk and disheveled Jimmy sitting on the curb of a sidewalk and informs him that they caught the boys who killed Katie. Jimmy Marcus is an ex … This quiz is based solely on the book. | Dave reaches his limit and confesses that he has to go outside and throw up. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. The lives of three men who were childhood friends are shattered when one of them has a family tragedy. Unusual? Edit, Mystic River (2001) was written by American author Dennis Lehane and adapted for the screen by American screenwriter Brian Helgeland. After Dave’s voice fades, Jimmy reflects upon the little guilt he felt over killing Ray, just an awareness—or fear—of karma. Sean takes the stick, squats down. He actually states "Boston Police found the body of a guy, a pedophile, in the woods behind McGill's. Why did the werewolf kill an “innocent” victim? What exactly was the Moon's "Evection Resonance"? How many matchsticks need to be removed so there are no equilateral triangles? To me, this felt like the screenplay cheated its way to resolution -- and I can't believe such a movie won Best Picture. Have I offended my professor by applying to summer research at other universities? A policeman comes along and takes Dave away with him. Jimmy and his friends confront Dave. Mystic River. Mystic River is a movie that reflects the idea that the strongest people in this world have ALL the choices while weak people have NO choice in this world. It reflects how the world cannot be separated into good people or bad people. Everyone begins to suspect Dave, who was seen with the victim before the murder and then came home later with an injured hand and blood on his clothes, supposedly from a mugging. That's why cops didn't get any news or body about that mugger Dave told about. Edit, The Mystic River is the name of a river in Boston. Celeste approaches, pale and unsteady (398). User Reviews | Is it implausible to the level of almost seeming like magic? Why didn't Dave just show Jimmy the body? We wash them clean," so some viewers see something more "mystical" in the title and have likened it metaphorically to karma, that is, what-goes-around-comes-around. Later, he kills Dave and also gets off scott-free. [Note: Dave was killed in the same location where Jimmy had shot and killed "Just Ray" Harris for ratting him out and sending him to jail for two years. Having more than one murder on a given night is not THAT implausible. Come on. After that, it becomes easy to blame Dave for doing criminal things to others, based on the erroneous assumption that "what goes around comes around." As the case unfolds, it looks more and more like Dave is the murderer. Well, of course, it wouldn't be a surprise ending if it was something completely normal. Even if Sean knows Jimmy killed Dave, there's no evidence for it, so he's literally be arresting on suspicion. He comes up with a story about a mugger. site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. In “Mystic River” how come no one mentioned the second murder? In that moment, Sean realizes that Jimmy has killed Dave but allows him to walk away, taking a phone call from his wife Lauren who talks with him for the first time and agrees to come home. Why would the military use tanks in a zombie apocalypses? MYSTIC RIVER by Brian Helgeland Based on the novel by Dennis Lehane NOTE: Please disregard ... YOUNG JIMMY Yeah, Dave, that must be it. At the beginning of the movie, Dave, Jimmy, and Sean were depicted as young boys playing in the street. Any recommendations for other movies similar to "Mystic River"? The "policeman" is actually a pedophile. 10. Jimmy admits to Dave that he killed "Just Ray" … "The last time I saw Dave Boyle," Jimmy says, "was 25 years ago going up the street in the back of a car." Directed by Clint Eastwood, the mysterious drama Mystic River is based on the novel by Dennis Lehane and adapted by screenwriter Brian Helgeland.
Cucala Lyrics English Translation, Homescapes Team Recruitment, Magnum And Higgins Kiss Fanfiction, Naruto Has A Angel Bloodline Fanfiction, Craigslist Okaloosa Barter, Cracked Bridging Servers,